Republic sought after writing really worth? Commented that at best when the light

A group of Republican primary composition books have recently published a reader question:

Republic sought after writing really worth?

Morning Glory Road, the reporter

Living in the Republic of Chen Jun, every primary school students probably will not think that he only described by a hundred-word essay, even in the 21st century will become sought after "Fan." Recently, the article, entitled "fair sun" to be included in an essay called "Republican primary composition" of the book, was that people talked about. Chen Jun, there are many people writing every age, has become the new darling of the eyes of publishers. This month, the Republican primary composition contains a variety of books suddenly cropped up several, some of them boarded the bestseller list.

However, the face of this bustling publishing trend, many readers can not help asking: "The Republic of writing, to the pursuit of modern people is really worth it?"

Scouring used book stalls selling book material

This time the "Republic essay," published in heat, began four months ago of a network of popular events. At the time, Billy was the Republican primary slope of the composition Lu "Spring outing in mind," put on the Internet, sparked heated debate between the moment. Various publishers keen to "sniff" to which business opportunities, soon began to dig a low-key piece of "hot spot." Planned publication of the "Republican primary school essay," Pan Qiulan said, the Republic of writing the book all drawn from Beixinshuju April 1937 issue of "primary creative library," "Back in April of this year, we started to the National Library and find the old book stalls, and finally found a set of five books in the library. "

The book was published, Pan Qiulan specifically went to Beijing Book Building investigation. Make her happy is within half an hour, there are three readers to buy the book. Other Republic of writing books also been sought after. Dangdang online, from the Guangxi People's Publishing House published another version of "the Republic of students writing" has earned its "five-star book list." Press even published a book immediately added the sequel. It is understood that in addition to primary composition, the Republic of secondary school students and been writing phase has even been included in the Republic of students writing the book was put on bookstore shelves.

Most readers "thick old book today"

In the eyes of many readers, from the hands of the Republican primary composition, seems to have become the ideological and literary sexy fine masterpiece. Such as Chen Jun by every "fair sun," the paper wrote: "sun in the sky, let the warm light all day long, shining all the characters, regardless of money, no money, can by its grace. "see this text, readers will have exclaimed," when the students actually have such a deep cultural literacy, and even adults today should be ashamed of ourselves. "

Writing in the Republic of the unique vernacular-style, today's readers are also much appreciated. Such as Zhang Yunsheng's "cricket" article: "play by the use of fighting crickets that Bo, while the crickets do not know who, Katsunori Showtime and hi, Baize unhappy and hate." It was emotion, not to mention write such an article, today's students probably have not even read the meaning of which are difficult. Internet users, "April Amy" laments: "It was the primary school of composition showing a natural childlike innocence, wisdom gracefully simple choice of words, non-modern people can."

In the pursuit of many readers, while the Republic of writing, but then had the students writing in today's harsh criticism. "Bud" magazine editor in chief Zhao days is strongly recommended by the Republic of writing, who has initiated the "new concept of writing contest," and made a star of the literary group of writers who severely criticized the star said, "We are now primary and secondary language education, the discourse Man, Practical and prose, essays, poetry, fiction cooked in a pot, a theme to be extracted; to say that a 'proper subject', many students had to say something without meaning everyone knows the major principles and even that insincere lies, that adults say. "

Republic of writing there are "impractical"

However, these claims come from outside, allows the primary school language teachers who feel wronged. Huajiadi Experimental Primary School fourth-grade language teachers Peng Ping, that now people are writing criticism of biased students, many people only see the one-sided situation. For example, she says, she in the classroom, students are encouraged to write their own are thinking, think outside the box and there is no limit. "We've let students follow the exam's baton, while the kids did not follow the routine to write anything, not like some people say, just write Mandarin, cliches, truths."

There are some readers that the Republic of writing in a matter of fact there are "impractical" phenomenon. Mr. Zhao was once the reader to the essay in the online popular "Spring outing in mind" as an example: "In all fairness, this essay is actually a running account, not more than today's students what thoughtful essay." He was even more concern is that Republic of writing these are mostly based on adult mentality by King lyrical, behind the text in the seemingly mature, there is no primary school should childlike at all, simply a "stereotyped." In his view, the nature of this violation of children's writing, today's kids do not study worth mentioning.

At best as a reference

From the perspective of language education, writing for today's Republican primary and secondary students have used to learn the value?

Media commentator Guo Zhendong that Republican primary school age children's lives, and today, the same educational backgrounds, do not have the strict sense of the comparability. "It was the era of the students have learned some of the content is relatively narrow, and modern students have learned the content has increased significantly, knowledge is quite different, sub-weak strength, even in the same qualified students, the Republic of fear it will be more on the composition special number. "

The Republic of writing by some readers in the semi-respected vernacular style, was also put forward different views. An education pointed out that the Republic of classical primary reading and writing is an essential tool, but now it is just a part of language teaching only, not to become a children's daily use of tools, this semi-blind respected classical style of writing, today's students do not have practical significance. In addition, Zhao day also pointed out that the emergence of this style, and then the rise of vernacular writing, just the "Republic of China is the vernacular of the start-up phase, the vernacular is not yet mature, is still not standardized."

Well-known scholar of culture, Relay Press deputy editor Huang Jiwei concluded: "blindly take the Republic of writing an essay today, compared with no meaning, and now the context of primary school students to live outside the Republic, they have been facing a completely different information environment, write good composition, temper talent to make the text truly become the hands of a dream tool, refer to the Republic of students writing only one. "