Zhao works are "pseudo-art" it? There has been controversy about him

Zhao works are "pseudo-art" it?

Exaggerated self-contradictory criticisms unconvincing

Recently, a literary forum in Beijing, there are many experts on the current literature and art "strange situation" to attack. Among them, most notably, last year criticized the Communication University of China Zhao drama professor Zeng Qingrui respect, Zhao's work is "pseudo-art", although this view caught the eye, but shocking.

There has been controversy

Zhao works really "pseudo-art" it? In this regard, Zengqing Rui said, "Zhao said, 'I can laugh the whole people across the country, you can do?" But laughter is the need to analyze, it should come from the aesthetic of the smile "rather than" to stimulate your senses satisfied, seductive does not raise heart smile. "

Of Zhao's work, critics have been in dispute. Zhao were to praise as the "maestro", "comedy king", "King of Comedy", "Oriental Chaplin", but he also criticized those who banished constantly, that his pieces have become more and more vulgar technology, to meet the vulgar.

However, the Zhao's work is dismissed as "pseudo-art", which is obviously by far the most radical criticism. Others do not say, for 20 consecutive years of Zhao board Gala, has been able to as a "comedy king" rule the roost in the show, if not his art to attract the audience laugh, then what is it? If the play is really fool Zhao's "pseudo-art", so that hundreds of millions of viewers really are "mentally retarded" do? The answer is clearly no.

Due to a conflict

In April last year, "Country Love Story" held in Beijing, Zhao first speech: "in the company, the people around every day, say good words, today, I want to hear 'bad things' and the truth, I always thank my suffering experienced people and my critics. "Unfortunately, when Professor Zeng Qingrui really tell the truth, the Uncle actually feeling angry, spot freak. At the time, Zeng Qingrui that, "Country Love Story" shows the life of the peasants of many scenes, clips, but the lack of "the true nature of the historical process." "One of the flat shape of the characters, not typical, there is no common background of the times group's identity. "" real reality TV to go to bypass, is a kind of pseudo-realism. "

Realistically speaking, Professor Zeng Qingrui's remarks, although some fierce criticism, but not unreasonable. For Zhao, there are corrections, if any, Tsutomu; if not agreed, can also be questionable, or even counter-criticism. But Zhao has suddenly fell out, rage, cynicism has taught to fight back on, a sudden "lip service" type of storm. At that time, almost one-sided, has taught in solidarity.

Before and after the conflict

Although the storm has passed more than a year, but the reporter has taught criticism from Zhao's work as "pseudo-art" words can still see his anger still lingers, rhetoric has been extreme. Last year, Professor Zeng said: "Mr. Hill is not the lack of skills, but more important is to pursue a more noble and more broad realm of feelings. Artists should be the pursuit of elegance, noble as the goal and the state." Rhetoric is also no shortage of good faith.

People see, last year, said the Professor, Mr. Hill is not a lack of skills of the artist, but this year accused him of "pseudo-art" of. Playing a "pseudo-art" people how to wear the artist's title it? Contradictory, apparently too serious. In all fairness, whether comedy or drama Zhao, two-person show, how can not be with the "pseudo-art" equate.

Unfair criticism

Zhao's work for a matter of opinion, evaluation of different completely normal. As Zhao's Sketch "donor", the TV drama "Country Love Story," and so a lot of controversy caused by the same. But critics it is "pseudo-art," apparently does not recognize to the point where it is art. This is excessive. Elegant and vulgar works of art are divided, there is good and mediocre in others, there is the difference between classical and popular, but to Zhao as "pseudo-art" name expelled from the arts, this is the first back. More seriously, yesterday, dozens of media outlets so much criticism is unfair.

Here I would like to borrow a famous scholar Yu Zhao a section on evaluation in conclusion: "In my opinion, Zhao comedy as a leading contemporary artists, is hundreds of millions of viewers judged by the whole China, and the test of time as long as ten years Zhao ... you can ignore, but can not ignore the hundreds of millions of people laugh for the choice. "Liang Yu Xin, chief reporter